Urinal spreaders are usually made from plastic, rubber, silicone, or occasionally stainless steel.
Plastic is the most common because it is cheap, lightweight, and easy to mold into different shapes. It works well for disposable or low-cost products, but it may wear out faster and can crack over time.
Rubber is flexible and soft, which helps it fit securely and provide a comfortable seal. It is usually better than basic plastic for durability and comfort, but it can absorb odors and may degrade if cleaned harshly.
Silicone is often the best all-around material. It is flexible, durable, heat-resistant, and easy to clean. It also resists odor and staining better than rubber or standard plastic. For reusable urinal spreaders, silicone is usually the top choice because it balances comfort, hygiene, and longevity.
Stainless steel is less common but very durable and easy to sanitize. However, it is heavier, more expensive, and not as flexible, so it is usually not the most practical option for a spreader.
Best overall: silicone, because it is durable, hygienic, comfortable, and long-lasting. If the goal is lowest cost, plastic is best. If the goal is maximum sturdiness and easy sterilization, stainless steel is best, though less convenient.